Opens in a new tab

AI IN RESEARCH ANALYSIS

Checking AI Data Analysis
An Audit Before You Submit

An analysis prepared with AI assistance is ready to submit when six things have been opened and verified, and this guide is the order in which a statistician opens them.

No Commitment Required

Strictly Confidential

In-House PhD-Level Statisticians

Fixed Project Fee

Same-Day Response

In Short

Checking AI data analysis means auditing six things in order: how the data were coded, whether the model fits the design, what the full output says, whether the assumptions hold on your data, whether the interpretation matches the evidence, and whether the whole analysis reruns from the raw file. Each step has something specific to open, something specific to look for and a defined action if it fails. The audit does not require distrusting AI, only treating its output as you would a colleague’s first draft: useful, and still in need of a second reader.

What AI Does Well When You Are Checking

AI is useful on the checking side too, because several verification tasks produce something you can compare.

A second implementation of the main model

Ask for the primary model in a different form, for example the same regression in SPSS syntax and in R. Matching estimates support the first script, and a mismatch tells you where to look.

A translation into a second language

A script translated from R to Python is an independent run on the same file. Agreement on counts, means and coefficients is evidence the logic is right.

A plain-English list of every transformation

Pasting a cleaning script and asking for each step in words exposes recodes you forgot you wrote. You verify the list against the code.

A regenerated descriptive table

Rebuilding the descriptive table from the raw file gives a baseline against which the model’s sample and the manuscript’s Table 1 can be compared.

Tables built from saved output

Formatting from the saved output file, not from numbers retyped into a chat, removes transcription as an error source.

A draft decision record

AI can turn your notes into a dated log of choices (exclusions, covariates, model changes). You correct it where it records what you intended instead of what you did.

Checking AI Data Analysis in Six Steps

Work through the steps in order, since a coding error found at step 1 changes everything after it.

1

1. Data coding

Open: the data dictionary and the recode section of the script. Look for: reverse-scored items, missing-value codes such as 99 or -9 being treated as real values, categories stored as numbers and analyzed as continuous, and value labels that disagree with the questionnaire. A failure looks like a 1 to 5 scale with a maximum of 99, or an average that moves when you drop one code. If found: correct the recode in the script, rerun everything downstream and log the change.

2

2. Model choice

Open: the protocol or analysis plan and the line of code that fits the model. Look for: an outcome type that matches the model (a binary outcome usually calls for logistic regression, and any other choice needs a stated reason), the unit of analysis, clustering or repeated measures, and covariates and primary outcome as prespecified. A failure looks like a model that appears nowhere in the plan. If found: name the intended model, rerun it, and label any other model exploratory in the manuscript.

3

3. Output

Open: the full output file, not the summary pasted into a chat. Look for: the N and degrees of freedom of every model, the sign and reference category of each coefficient, estimates consistent with their intervals and p-values, and warnings about convergence or singular fits. A failure looks like a warning scrolled past, or an N three lower than the dataset. If found: resolve the warning or explain the exclusion before any estimate is quoted.

4

4. Assumptions

Open: the diagnostics the script produced. Look for: residuals against fitted values, influence statistics, collinearity, overdispersion for counts, and proportional hazards for Cox regression. Judge each in context, asking whether the departure is large enough to change the estimate or its interval. A failure looks like no diagnostics at all, or a sentence stating that assumptions hold with nothing behind it. If found: run them, and report a robust or alternative specification beside the main one.

5

5. Interpretation

Open: the results paragraph next to the tables. Look for: an interval beside each estimate, wording that matches the design (association for observational data), a non-significant result described as proof of no effect, units (per standard deviation or per unit), and the number of outcomes tested. A failure looks like “proves” or “confirms” attached to a single p-value. If found: rewrite each sentence to say only what the estimate, its interval and the design support.

6

6. Reproducibility

Open: a clean session with nothing in memory. Look for: a script that runs from the raw file to every table, numbers that match the manuscript, recorded software and package versions, and random seeds set where randomness is used. A failure looks like a script that only works with objects left over from earlier work, or tables typed in by hand. If found: rebuild a single run-from-start script and archive it with the output.

What Must Still Be Confirmed

The audit above tells you what to open. These five confirmations are what a statistician adds, and what to send them.

1

The method fits the design

Send the protocol or study description and the data dictionary. The statistician confirms the unit of analysis, the primary outcome and how clustering or repeated measures were handled.

2

Assumptions are checked on the actual data

Send the script and the dataset. The statistician runs the diagnostics themselves and decides whether any departure matters for the estimate.

3

The numbers reproduce from the raw file

Send the original, unedited file, not a cleaned copy alone. The statistician reruns from the raw file and compares each reported number.

4

The reporting matches the guideline

Send the target journal and the manuscript’s Methods and Results. The statistician checks them against the relevant reporting guideline.

5

The data stayed where it was allowed to be

Tell the statistician which tools touched the file and under what terms, so the manuscript’s data statement is accurate.

How to Disclose AI Use in Your Manuscript

Policies differ by journal, so confirm the target journal's instructions. The full table of six publishers, editorial bodies and funders is on the hub guide, AI Data Analysis: What AI Can Do With Research Data and What a Statistician Confirms.

POLICY TABLE · Last checked November 2026 · rechecked every six months
Who What must be disclosed Where in the paper Source URL
ICMJE Whether AI-assisted technologies were used in producing the work; AI cannot be listed as an author Cover letter, and the relevant section of the manuscript Policy page ↗
Elsevier Tool name and purpose for AI used in manuscript preparation; basic grammar and spelling checks need no declaration Statement at the end of the manuscript above the references; AI in the research process, in Methods Policy page ↗
Wiley Use of AI technologies disclosed at submission; AI cannot be listed as an author Acknowledgments (drafting, editing, translation); Methods (research methodology); figure captions Policy page ↗
EXAMPLE WORDING (ADAPT TO THE JOURNAL)

“AI-suggested code for [analysis] was reviewed by the authors, rerun from the raw data in a clean session and compared with an independent implementation before results were reported.”

“The full analysis script, software versions and decision record are available [where].”

How OnlineSPSS Works With AI-Assisted Analysis

OnlineSPSS does not offer "AI analysis" as a service and does not certify, rank or recommend AI tools. Two services fit the two situations below.

You did the analysis with AI

Independent Statistical Review accepts analyses that the client prepared with AI assistance. The review checks method, assumptions, reproducibility and reporting, the same as for any analysis.

The data cannot be uploaded anywhere

Client data are never uploaded to any AI service. Analysis runs locally on company devices.

The Audit as a Tick List

Copy the list below into your project notes and tick each line only after you have opened the file named in it.

  • Data coding: dictionary and recodes opened; missing-value codes, reversed items and variable types verified.
  • Model choice: the fitted model matches the analysis plan, the outcome type and the unit of analysis.
  • Output: full output file read; N, degrees of freedom, signs, reference categories and warnings checked.
  • Assumptions: diagnostics produced, read and, where needed, followed by a sensitivity analysis.
  • Interpretation: each sentence matches the design and carries its interval.
  • Reproducibility: the script reruns from the raw file in a clean session and the numbers match the manuscript.

The reproducibility package

Keep these six items together, since a reviewer or collaborator can rerun the analysis from them (Sandve et al., 2013).

  1. The verified script, the version that produced the reported tables, not an earlier draft.
  2. The data version and the cleaning decisions: which file, which exclusions, which recodes and why.
  3. Software and package versions, with random seeds where used.
  4. The output and the log from the final run.
  5. The decision record: choices made, who made them and which were prespecified or exploratory.
  6. The saved chat, kept as a supporting record only. A chat transcript alone may not reconstruct an analysis (Dunn et al., 2026).

Frequently Asked Questions

Open the data dictionary, the model call, the full output, the diagnostics and the results paragraph, then rerun the script from the raw file. The order matters, because each later step relies on the data being coded correctly. Each step has a defined failure and a defined correction, which is what the six-step audit lays out.

It can draft an independent implementation and flag inconsistencies, and agreement between two runs is useful evidence about the code. It cannot confirm that the method fits your design. Treat the comparison as one check, not the verdict.

Reviewers tend to ask why the method was chosen, how missing data were handled, whether results can be reproduced and what the authors verified. They may also ask how AI use was disclosed and whether that statement matches your records. Keep the script, the decision record and the evidence of your checks ready.

Check the data version, the software and package versions and any random seed first. Output that changes with a fixed script and data points to an uncontrolled setting. If a language model sits inside the live analysis, rerun it several times and report the variation.

Independent Statistical Review checks method, assumptions, reproducibility and reporting, the same as for any analysis, including analyses prepared with AI assistance. A statistically trained Research Coordinator reviews the request first, and the scope is confirmed before work begins. You keep authorship and responsibility for the study.

References

Policy table last checked November 2026 · rechecked every six months · Reviewed by an in-house statistician

Have a Statistician Run the Audit

Send the script, the output and the data file you used. A statistically trained Research Coordinator reviews the request, and the scope and one fixed project fee are confirmed before work begins.

Request an Assessment

Nothing you send us is uploaded to any AI service.