Opens in a new tab

Home / Resources / AI in Research

What Reviewers Expect From an AI-Assisted Analysis:
Decisions, Records and an Independent Check

In peer review of an AI-assisted analysis, reviewers assess the research, not whether the author used a particular AI tool. They may need to understand why a method was chosen, how data and missingness were handled, whether results can be reproduced and how AI's contribution was checked. Disclosure rules differ, but human authors remain accountable for their submitted findings (International Committee of Medical Journal Editors [ICMJE], 2026; Sandve et al., 2013).

AI in Research
WHO ASKSReviewers, editors
WHEREMethods, AI declaration
KEEPCode and audit trail
NEVERClaim unmade checks
LAST CHECKEDNovember 2026

AI can be an efficient way to produce code or explain an output. The aim of verification is to preserve that benefit while making the methods and interpretation understandable to another researcher.

What questions could peer review raise about an AI-assisted analysis?

The questions below are examples derived from general research-methods and reporting standards, not an official checklist applied by every journal.

POLICY TABLE · Last checked November 2026 · rechecked every six months

Possible reviewer question Evidence the authors could provide
Why was this model selected? Study objective, design, outcome definition, analysis plan and alternatives considered
Did the analysis use the correct observations? Eligibility rules, sample flow, exclusions and missing-data strategy
Were assumptions examined? Relevant diagnostic checks and decisions taken when assumptions were questionable
Can someone reproduce the results? Final executable code, data access conditions, software versions and fixed analysis inputs
How was AI used? Honest task-specific disclosure and a record of human verification
Who is accountable for the interpretation? Authors’ methodological explanations and clear responsibility for conclusions

A reviewer may raise the same questions when no AI was used. The difference is that an AI-assisted workflow benefits from a clear record of which recommendations came from the tool and which were approved or modified by the researcher.

Why is a statistical output without errors not enough?

A model can run successfully while failing to address the prespecified study question. For example, a regression might ignore repeated measurements, use a different outcome definition, or silently analyze only complete records. These are methodological questions. The relevant check is not merely whether the numerical output resembles what was expected but whether the code implemented a justified analysis on the correct data (Hernán & Robins, 2020; Carpenter & Smuk, 2021).

Research on AI coding has demonstrated useful capabilities alongside the need for task-specific review. Winberg et al. (2026) found accurate code generation for several textbook quantitative problems, while also reporting cases requiring correction and the variation of code across users and runs. Such work supports careful use of AI, not automatic distrust or automatic acceptance.

What should an AI-assisted analysis audit trail contain?

A proportionate audit record could include:

  1. The approved study protocol or analysis plan, including any documented departures.
  2. The dataset version, eligibility criteria, variable definitions and analysis population.
  3. The actual code and software environment used to create each table and figure.
  4. A note describing AI’s role, tool/model details if available, and any substantive generated recommendations.
  5. Records of methodological review, including assumptions, missing-data treatment and selected independent checks.
  6. A mapping between analysis outputs and manuscript claims, including revisions.

This is a suggested good-practice checklist, not a claim that every item is universally mandated. Sandve et al. (2013) explain why saved scripts, traceable changes and documented computational environments support reproducibility.

What does an independent statistician add?

An independent statistical reviewer can assess whether the model matches the research question, whether the analysis population is consistent, whether assumptions were handled appropriately and whether the interpretation is supported by the estimates. The purpose is not to “prove AI failed” or to replace the responsible authors. It is to add a second, documented methodological assessment before the work reaches a committee or journal.

Independent review is sensible in some high-stakes or technically complex settings, but it is not a universal formal requirement for all manuscripts. The review should be scaled to the study and should report material limitations rather than guarantee acceptance.

How much should authors say about AI in the manuscript?

The ICMJE recommends disclosure of AI-assisted technologies and their uses, with authors retaining responsibility for accuracy, integrity and originality (ICMJE, 2026). For analysis-related assistance, a short declaration may be supplemented by the Methods section, where the actual statistical decisions and validation procedures belong.

Illustrative description, to be adapted only if true:

EXAMPLE WORDING (ADAPT TO THE JOURNAL)

Generative AI was used to suggest and troubleshoot statistical code for the planned analyses. All analyses were executed in the approved computing environment. The research team checked variable coding, analysis samples, model specifications and interpretation, and [independent reviewer, where applicable] verified [specified components]. The authors remain responsible for the reported findings.

Do not claim independent validation, fully local analysis or anonymization unless it actually occurred. Do not upload protected manuscripts, reviewer reports or participant-level datasets to unapproved AI tools as part of the review process.

Frequently asked questions

No. Independent review is a quality-control step; it does not imply that the original calculation was incorrect. It is similar in purpose to having another qualified researcher check a complex analysis.

That depends on the journal and the research procedure. Preserve a defensible internal record and disclose what the journal requires. Prompts are not a substitute for the final executable analysis.

A conversation may not produce identical responses in later sessions or model versions. A reproducibility package should therefore preserve the actual analysis code, inputs, environment and output, subject to data-access restrictions (Sandve et al., 2013).

The authors and research team retain responsibility. The AI tool may assist with tasks, but it cannot become an accountable journal author under ICMJE guidance.

Independent Statistical ReviewNeed a statistician to confirm the analysis before you submit? An in-house PhD-level statistician reviews the method, the assumptions and the reporting before the work goes to a reviewer.

Request an Assessment

Independent Statistical Review

OnlineSPSS provides Independent Statistical Review through in-house PhD-level statisticians. The review checks method, assumptions, reproducibility and reporting, while the research question, interpretation and conclusions remain with the research team. Independent Statistical Review covers analyses prepared with AI assistance.

References

Last reviewed November 2026 by the OnlineSPSS Statistical Team. Worked examples use hypothetical values and are not client data.

NEXT STEP

Need this done for
your study?

Share your research in about a minute and receive a complimentary assessment the same day: scope, timeline and one fixed fee.

No Commitment Required

Strictly Confidential

Fixed Project Fee

In-House PhD-Level Statisticians

Same-Day Response

Serving Researchers Since 2014